Jane celebrated her 21st birthday and graduation party at a very exclusive venue paid for by her parents. Her aunt, Debra, was so excited and gave Jane an expensive jewellery set to congratulate her. Six months later, Aunt Debra informs Jane that she wants the jewellery set back because she is unable to pay her municipal rates.

What is the CORRECT legal position?

Question

Jane celebrated her 21st birthday and graduation party at a very exclusive venue paid for by her parents. Her aunt, Debra, was so excited and gave Jane an expensive jewellery set to congratulate her. Six months later, Aunt Debra informs Jane that she wants the jewellery set back because she is unable to pay her municipal rates.  
 
 What is the  CORRECT  legal position?

Answer

Aunt Debra can claim the jewellery set from Jane on the ground of unjustified enrichment.

Answer

Jane is obliged to give back the jewellery set, but she can claim damages from Aunt Debra.

Answer

Aunt Debra is not entitled to take the jewellery set back, because a valid contract of donation was concluded.

Answer

Aunt Debra is entitled to take back the jewellery set, because the contract of donation should have been in writing and signed by Aunt Debra.

Crowdly

Jane celebrated her 21st birthday and graduation party at a very exclusive venue...

Want instant access to all verified answers on claw.myexams.unisa.ac.za?