During a classroom discussion about whether universities should adopt limit student protests at university that disrupt classroom activies, Liam suddenly becomes quiet after another student shares a strong opposing view. When asked if he wants to respond, he says, “No — this is exactly why these discussions never go anywhere,” and stops engaging.
Which of the following responses would best support constructive engagement with this situation?

(Select all that apply)

Question

During a classroom discussion about whether universities should adopt limit student protests at university that disrupt classroom activies, Liam suddenly becomes quiet after another student shares a strong opposing view. When asked if he wants to respond, he says, “No — this is exactly why these discussions never go anywhere,” and stops engaging. 
 Which of the following responses would best support constructive engagement with this situation? 
 
 (Select all that apply)

Accepted Answer

Encourage the group to focus on the logical structure of the arguments rather than emotional reactions.

Accepted Answer

Suggest pausing briefly to give Liam and others the space to reflect on their emotions before continuing the discussion.

Accepted Answer

Acknowledge that strong emotional responses are common in normative disagreements and can signal what values are at stake.

Answer

Move on to a less emotionally charged topic to maintain a productive atmosphere.

Answer

Ask Liam to explain to everyone why he feels strongly before continuing the discussion.

Crowdly

During a classroom discussion about whether universities should adopt limit stu...

Want instant access to all verified answers on learning.monash.edu?